# Gate 2A Review Index

**Status:** Accepted by owner July 19, 2026; Gate 2B.1 primary scenes ready for owner review  
**Review question:** Do these definitions capture what makes the three Realms genuinely different, alive, contributive, and trustworthy before any interface is designed?

## Recommended review path

### 1. Canonical change — 5 minutes

- `references/canonical-taxonomy-v1.3.3.md` — review the opening Field changes and final **Version 1.3.3 Canonical Boundary**.
- `TAXONOMY_IMPACT_LOG.md` — compact change record.

Decision requested: **Accept / revise / reject the 1.3.3 clarifications.** Atlas, Focus, Pulse, Lens, Stage, and one-center shell remain non-canonical.

### 2. Shared behavior — 10 minutes

- `COLLECTIVE_AGENCY_MODEL.md`
- `FIELD_REALM_SURFACE_RELATIONSHIPS.md`

Decision requested: **Is the proposed authority/contribution/attention model strong enough to express a living Field without creating a notification center or surveillance system?**

### 3. Realm contracts — 15–25 minutes

- `REALM_INNER_CLINIC.md`
- `REALM_NATURE_OF_WORK.md`
- `REALM_2ND_CAVALRY_SERVICE_ALLIANCE.md`

Decision requested for each: **Does this Realm's purpose, Stance, contribution model, authority, and safety boundary feel true? What should be kept, changed, or removed?**

### 4. Comparison and next visual test — 10 minutes

- `CROSS_REALM_BEHAVIOR_MATRIX.md`
- `GATE_2B_SCENE_BRIEFS.md`

Decision requested: **Are these exactly the six scenes that should test Gate 2B?** No scene has been built.

### 5. Evidence and open questions — as needed

- `SOURCE_REGISTER.md`
- `GATE_2A_EVIDENCE_LEDGER.md`
- `CONTRADICTION_REGISTER.md`
- `GATE_2A_INTENTION_AND_EXCEPTION_FLOWS.md`
- `GATE_2A_COMPLETION_AUDIT.md`

## Gate 2A artifact map

| Deliverable | File | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Canonical Taxonomy 1.3.3 + change log | `references/canonical-taxonomy-v1.3.3.md`; `TAXONOMY_IMPACT_LOG.md` | Complete; owner review needed |
| Source versions and provenance | `SOURCE_REGISTER.md` | Complete for supplied/checked sources |
| Requirement/evidence/proposal separation | `GATE_2A_EVIDENCE_LEDGER.md` | Complete |
| Contradictions and missing evidence | `CONTRADICTION_REGISTER.md` | Complete; 19 items open |
| Shared collective-agency/contribution model | `COLLECTIVE_AGENCY_MODEL.md` | Proposed; review needed |
| Field/Realm/Panel/Scene/Portal/Atlas semantics | `FIELD_REALM_SURFACE_RELATIONSHIPS.md` | Canonical boundary + proposals; review needed |
| Inner Clinic contract | `REALM_INNER_CLINIC.md` | Complete working contract; Seed readiness |
| Nature of Work contract | `REALM_NATURE_OF_WORK.md` | Complete working contract; Seed readiness |
| 2nd Cavalry / Service Alliance contract | `REALM_2ND_CAVALRY_SERVICE_ALLIANCE.md` | Complete working contract; Seed readiness |
| Nine intentions + nine exceptions | `GATE_2A_INTENTION_AND_EXCEPTION_FLOWS.md` | Complete |
| Cross-Realm comparison | `CROSS_REALM_BEHAVIOR_MATRIX.md` | Complete |
| Six Gate 2B briefs + criteria | `GATE_2B_SCENE_BRIEFS.md` | Complete recommendation; not built |
| Logs and plan | `DECISION_LOG.md`; `OPEN_DECISIONS.md`; `WORKING_PLAN.md` | Updated |
| Completion audit | `GATE_2A_COMPLETION_AUDIT.md` | Complete |

## What has deliberately not happened

- No accepted Gate 1 prototype file changed.
- No Gate 2 interface or high-fidelity scene was created.
- No Atlas was designed.
- No production code or Flutter/Flame architecture was written.
- No confidential SADUNA planning was placed into public scene content.
- No missing clinical, legal, organizational, archive, or governance authority was invented.

## Suggested owner response format

```text
Taxonomy 1.3.3: accept / revise / reject

Collective agency model:
- Keep:
- Change:
- Remove:

Inner Clinic:
- Keep:
- Change:
- Remove:

The Nature of Work:
- Keep:
- Change:
- Remove:

2nd Cavalry / Service Alliance:
- Keep:
- Change:
- Remove:

Gate 2B six-scene set: accept / revise
Specific scene changes:
```
